Note: I am updating the song list a little at a time.
Murder
outnumbers any other subject for a ballad topic. Jody Amable, in a
January 30, 2021 article for JSTOR daily, referred to murder ballads
as “...the original true crime podcast”. In the article Amable
quoted Harold Schechter who wrote in The Yale Review that murder
ballads were “the oldest form of crime literature”. Ballads
began as news stories which would be printed on broadsides, one of
the first forms of printed news, which carried the news of the day.
The most sensational stories, often having to do with a trial,
especially if it involved murder, would be sung in ballad form on
sidewalks by those hawking the broadsides. For those who couldn't
read this was the only way they got any news. Many of our ballads
were brought over from Europe, especially the British Isles, when emigrants left their homeland for a new home thousands of miles away.
Over the course of time many broadside ballads undoubtedly faded away into
obscurity while others endured and are sung about still albeit in an
altered form.
After
the emigrants and their songs crossed the Atlantic, locations and
details, even the titles, of songs would get altered somewhat. For instance,
the murderous tale of “The Oxford Girl” in England became “The
Wexford Girl” in Ireland and “The Knoxville Girl” in Kentucky,
U. S. A. If you listen carefully the stories are basically the same.
A boy takes up with a girl, promises to marry said girl, who may or
may not be pregnant, and one day they spend some time walking, or
riding, and, supposedly, talking about their wedding to be and fixing
a date. All the while, and unbeknownst to her, he's planning to kill
her. She is either stabbed and pushed into a river or beaten with a
large stick and dragged by her hair and put into a river. In one
instance a young lady is given poisoned wine. I highlight a few ballads
below, hopefully without giving too much away.
In
the 19th century murder ballad “Banks of the Ohio”, also known as
“Down on the Banks of the Ohio”, a young man named Willie is
spurned when his lady love rejects his marriage proposal. Once alone,
and obviously unable to take “no” for an answer, he murders her.
Unlike other murder ballads, this murderer explains why he killed his
beloved and goes on to express his sorrow and regret. There isn't
much background on this one so I don't know if it really happened or
was made up for entertainment.
The
ballad “Omie Wise” tells of the murder of Naomi 'Omie' Wise in
1808 in Randolph County, North Carolina. She had gotten pregnant by
her young man, John Lewis, who beguiled her with the promise of “some
jewels and many other fine things”.
“Tom
Dooley” is likewise based on an actual murder, also committed in
North Carolina, but in Wilkes County. Tom's surname was Dula but was
pronounced Dooley. In 1866 he murdered his lover Laura Foster, who
was carrying their unborn child, by stabbing her to death with a
large knife. Anne Foster Melton, Laura Foster's cousin, had been Dula's
lover long before he left for the Civil War. Upon his returning from the war he and Anne resumed their affair even though she had married a much older man, James Melton. While
Dula continued to carry on with Anne he took up with her cousin Laura
and also their cousin Pauline Foster. It was comments made by Pauline
that led to the discovery of Laura's body. Accusations were made
against both Dula and Anne Foster Melton. On Dula's sworn word that she had nothing
to do with the killing Anne Foster Melton was acquitted. On the gallows, however,
Dula said he had not harmed Laura but still deserved punishment. This
led to speculation that Anne Foster Melton was indeed the killer
which would mean Dula went to the gallows in her place. Local poet
Thomas Land wrote a song about the tragedy entitled “Tom Dooley”
not long after Dula was hung.
“The
Long Black Veil”, a country music classic, began as a poem written by Danny Dill who, in 1959, presented it to Marijohn
Wilkin who fine tuned it. Dill said he drew on three sources for inspiration: the song “God
Walks These Hills With Me" which was recorded by Red Foley, the
contemporary newspaper report about the unsolved murder of a priest,
and the
legend of a mysterious veiled woman who regularly visited actor Rudolph
Valentino's grave. It was
originally recorded by Lefty Frizzell March 3, 1959 and released a few weeks later on April 20th. The story is told from the point of view of a man
falsely accused of killing a man. He would have been let go if he was
somewhere else at the time of the killing, which he was, but he wouldn't
give up that information. Wilkin wrote and recorded an answer to “The
Long Black Veil” in 1960 entitled “My Long Black Veil” but it
was never released and we'll likely never know why. I stumbled upon
it while browsing YouTube. In “The Long Black Veil” it's said the
woman stood in the crowd and shed not a tear, which I always thought
was cold until I realized that if she cried a little too loud or too
much it would get folks to speculating and set gossiping tongues to
wagging. In the answer song the woman tells her side of the story in
which we learn she did cry, she just did so inwardly. Now fast
forward 50 some odd years to the 21st century. Texas/Red Dirt artist Jason Boland wrote a song entitled
“False Accuser's Lament”. By the time he got through with it he
realized it could be the backstory for “The Long Black Veil”.
It's not where he was headed when he started writing “False
Accuser's Lament” but it's where he ended up. From the time I first
heard it, long before hearing his explanation, as told on an episode
on the internet show “The Texas Connection”, I thought of “The
Long Black Veil”. I only discovered Marijohn Wilkin's answer song
just a couple of years ago long after first hearing “False
Accuser's Lament”. This story is pure fiction.
The
story of the murders of David “Stringbean” and Estelle Akeman is
told in “The Ballad of Stringbean and Estelle”. As it happened on
November 10, 1973, which was a little more than two months after my
tenth birthday, my memory of the story is vague. I do, however,
remember Stringbean being part of the cast of the country music variety
show "Hee-Haw". He was a singer-songwriter, musician, comedian, actor
and semi-professional baseball player. On that November night
Stringbean had a show on the Grand Ole Opry. During that time two
burglars, seeking money alleged to be hidden in the home, were lying in wait at the Akeman's rural Tennessee home near
Ridgetop. The couple was killed shortly after arriving home. Close
friend, neighbor, and fellow "Hee-Haw" cast member Louis "Grandpa" Jones
discovered the bodies the next day. All the killers got was a
chainsaw and some firearms, although they expected more than that, in
addition to very long prison sentences. Something interesting
happened when the home was torn down some time after the murders but
you'll have to listen to the song to find out what it was.
Stringbean
While
murder ballads have waned in popularity, the idea of them has not
been put away in the storehouse of time. There are still ballads out
there that tell a tale of murder, revenge for murder, the
implication of murder and murder-suicide. It's not always because
of a beau's soured heart or a sweetheart's rejection. In “When It's Springtime
in Alaska” the guy who comes in from the back of beyond choses to
dance with the wrong gal. In “Down the River” a man is shot and
killed by someone he had a fight with the week before. Even though
the death in “I Hung My Head” is caused by an accidental shooting
it's the shooter's response that makes it look bad. In “Independence
Day” an abused wife takes matters into her own hands. “The Legend
of Wooley Swamp” is both a murder and a ghost story. When you
listen to a song be sure to hear the words so you get the story.
I
have made a partial list of American ballads, including, of course, those
brought over from Europe and altered over time after reaching America, in which
murder takes place. I'm sure I may have missed quite a few or more.
While they are primarily country there is also bluegrass, blues, folk
and other genres. I list with the songs at least one singer known to have
sung it even though most have been covered by many other artists. I'll note, too, if the ballad is based on an actual event. Any of these can be found by doing a search on YouTube.
- "A Prisoner's Diary", Leon Payne
- "Ain't It Sad to Stand and Watch Love Die", Conway Twitty
- "The Ballad of Annie Palmer", Johnny Cash
- "The
Ballad of Emmett Till", Bob Dylan (based on an actual event)
- "The Ballad
of Hollis Brown", Bob Dylan
- "The Ballad of John Rollin", Walter 'Tex' Dixon
- "The Ballad of Sarah Malone", David Davis
- "The
Ballad of Stringbean and Estelle", Sam Bush (based on an actual event)
- "Banks
of the Ohio", Johnny Cash
- " Billy Paul", Vince Gill
- "Blackadders Cove", New Found Road
- "Blood Red and Going Down", Tanya Tucker
- "Bow Down Your Head and Cry", Charlie Walker
- "Caney Fork River", Balsam Range
- "Cedar
Town, Georgia", Waylon Jennings
- "Cocaine
Blues" (also known as "Little Sadie"), Johnny Cash
- "Cold
Hard Facts of Life", Porter Wagoner
- "Cross the Brazos at Waco", Billy Walker
- "Delia's
Gone", Johnny Cash
- "Delilah",
Tom Jones
- "Della
and the Dealer", Hoyt Axton
- "Devil's Right Hand", Steve Earle (added 07/05/2023)
- "Don't
Take Your Guns to Town", Johnny Cash
- "Down
in the Willow Garden", Charlie Monroe
- "Down
the River", Chris Knight
- "El
Paso", Marty Robbins
- "The
Everglades", Waylon Jennings
- "False
Accuser's Lament", Jason Boland & The Stragglers
- "Folsom
Prison Blues", Johnny Cash
- "Frankie and Johnny", Jimmie Rodgers, many others (added 07/05/2023)
- "Goodbye,
Earl", The (Dixie) Chicks
- "Guilty
as Can Be", Cody Johnson
- "I
Hung My Head", Johnny Cash
- "I
Killed Sally's Lover", The Avett Brothers
- "I Left My Gal in the Mountains", Hank Thompson (added 07/05/2023)
- "I
Never Picked Cotton", Roy Clark
- "In
the Ghetto", Mac Davis
- "In
the Pines (Where Did You Sleep Last Night)", Lead Belly (The difference between this version and “In the Pines” by The Louvin Bros., Mac
Wiseman, & others is that the latter version leaves out the implication of murder.)
- "Independence
Day", Martina McBride
- "Jenny
Lou", Sonny James
- "The
Knoxville Girl", The Louvin Brothers
- "The
Legend of Wooley Swamp", Charlie Daniels
- "Lily of the West", Bob Dylan (added 07/05/2023)
- "Little Glass of Wine", Stanley Brothers (added 07/05/2023)
- "Little
Omie Wise", Doc Watson (based on an actual event)
- "Little
Sadie" (also known as "Cocaine Blues"), Doc Watson
- "My
Long Black Veil", Marijohn Wilkin
- "The
Long Black Veil", Lefty Frizzell
- "L. A. County", Lyle Lovett (added 07/05/2023)
- "Loving
County", Charlie Robison
- "Miller's
Cave", Bobby Bare
- "Matty
Groves", Doc Watson
- "The
Murder of the Lawson Family", Walter Smith & Friends (based on an
actual event)
- "The
Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia", Reba McEntire & Vicky
Lawrence
- *"Open Pit Mine", George Jones (added 10/19/2022)
- "Papa
Loved Mama", Garth Brooks
- "Poor Ellen Smith", Country Gentlemen (added 07/05/2023)
- "Pretty
Polly", Estil C Ball
- *"Radio Lover", George Jones (added 10/19/2022)
- "Red
Georgia Clay", John Anderson
- "Red Headed Stranger", Willie Nelson (added 07/05/2023)
- "River
Bottom", The Country Gentlemen
- "Rose
in Paradise", Waylon Jennings (murder is implied)
- "Running
Gun", Marty Robbins
- "Stagger
Lee", Lloyd Price
- "Stagger
Mountain Tragedy", Kris Kristofferson
- "Sugar
Man", Kris Kristofferson
- "Take
Me Back to Jackson", Carl Butler (murder is implied)
- "Tall
Lover Man", June Carter Cash
- "That
Georgia Sun Was Blood Red and Goin' Down", Tanya Tucker
- "The
Veil of White Lace", Mel Tillis
- "They're
Hanging Me Tonight", Marty Robbins
- "Tom Dooley", The Kingston Trio and Peter, Paul & Mary (added 07/05/2023)
- "When
It's Springtime in Alaska", Johnny Horton
I'm
on the fence concerning “Play, Guitar, Play”, by Conway Twitty,
whether it could be a murder ballad by implication. With Waylon
Jennings' “Rose in Paradise” and Carl Butler's “Take Me Back to
Jackson” there is enough said to imply murder may have been
committed but not so with “Play, Guitar, Play”. The man in the
song surely done something wrong. First, the man in the song wants to
hear his momma calling “Look a-yonder ya-all who's coming down the
road, he's a coming home..” but, he says, “they know I never
will”. Second, he mentions leaving them, presumably his family,
“with that awful thing I done”, how he didn't say a word and just
packed his clothes and ran. Third, he's apparently on the move. He
mentions singing one more song before having to move along to
“another town, another crowd”, and wondering “if they know”,
asking himself “can they read between the lines in my song as I
sing about a good boy that went wrong”.
Sources for information:
The Miller's Apprentice , Omie Wise , Yale Review Essay on Omie Wise
Pretty Polly , Banks of the Ohio , Matty Groves
Down in the Willow Garden , The Long Black Veil
Tom Dooley , Delia's Gone , David 'Stringbean' Akeman
The Lawson Family , Emmett Till , Stagger Lee
Jody Amable's Jan. 30, 2021 JSTOR Daily article
List of Murder Ballads at Wikipedia (added 10/19/2022)
For more information on songs not mentioned above, just do a "murder ballads" search at google.
Revised and updated 9/25/22. tkp
Update again 10/18/2022. tkp